July 16, 2019

Maine Fish And Game Slapped With A Lawsuit

The Animal Protection Institute, made up of a group that finds protecting a few animals more pleasurable than the welfare of human beings, has filed a lawsuit against the Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife.

The Animal Protection Institute (API) today filed suit against the Maine Department of Inland Fisheries & Wildlife (IF&W) to stop the agency from continuing to violate the Endangered Species Act (ESA) by allowing trappers to use traps that injure and sometimes kill threatened and endangered species.

In April 2006, API sent a letter of intent to sue the Maine IF&W in an effort to prompt the agency to take immediate actions to protect imperiled species from deadly body-gripping traps and snares. API and the State were unable to reach a mutually satisfactory resolution of the issue.

Through a press release of their own, the MDIFW countered the accusations of API.

“The Department of Inland Fisheries & Wildlife works with the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service to ensure that all reasonable precautions are taken to minimize the potential take of lynx and ensure that regulated trapping is no threat to lynx populations; and clearly, banning trapping in the State of Maine is not our preferred option,” said Roland D. Martin, Commissioner of the Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife.

Maine has a larger lynx population than any other eastern state, and Maine’s bald eagle population is the largest in the northeast. Maine does not have a gray wolf population.

“Trapping is an important wildlife management activity that is highly regulated to ensure that wildlife populations continue to be healthy,” said Ken Elowe, Director, Bureau of Resource Management for the Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife.

“Maine is known nationwide as a leader in collaborative research and conservation of lynx. Currently, the department is in the midst of a 6-year lynx research project that has provided as much or more lynx habitat and status information as any other study in the lower 48 states,” said Martin. This lynx project is a collaboration between the Maine Department of Inland Fisheries & Wildlife, the University of Maine, Maine Cooperative Fish & Wildlife Research Unit, U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service, and several commercial forest landowners.

The Department continues to work with trappers to incorporate best management practices into trapping. The department also published a pamphlet for trappers entitled “How To Avoid Incidental Take of Lynx” which was written and distributed to reduce the possibility of trapping lynx while trapping other furbearers. A few lynx are killed each year by cars, predators such as bobcats and fisher, and occasionally caught incidentally during the regulated trapping season.

The API would rather spew incorrect and misleading information as part of their public relations campaign to end all forms of hunting, fishing and trapping along with a long list of other foolish measures they believe will protect animals.

Through public records requests, API discovered that species listed under the federal ESA, including Canada lynx and Bald eagles, have been captured and sometimes seriously injured or killed in body-gripping traps and snares set for other species. In Maine, a minimum of five threatened Canada lynx were caught in traps in 2005 alone; at least two of the lynx killed were kittens.

Considering the number of traps and trappers trying to eke out a living and supplementing their incomes, it is quite clear to me they are doing a pretty good job at keeping incidental occurrences to a minimum. But API doesn’t care about the welfare of Mainers who rely on trapping to live nor do they care whether trapping is an extremely important part of wildlife management to ensure a healthy bunch of animals. No, their bent is to outlaw it all and force their off-the-wall beliefs on the rest of us. They use the notion that their interest is in protecting innocent animals and it’s not. Their interest is themselves and forcing their minority ways on everyone else through lawsuits.

If I judge were to rule in favor of API’s lawsuit, it would clear the way to begin outlawing any practice in Maine and all across America that could possibly risk injury or death to any endangered species. This would include driving of cars, trucks, busses, planes, trains, boats, as all of these do and can kill or harm these animals. The point being is that the API are a bunch of fools wasting taxpayers money in order to promote personal agendas.

I am sure that API opted to sue Maine thinking that because the state is comparatively poor, it wouldn’t have the resources to fight a suit. Camilla Fox, director of API said she was disappointed that Maine didn’t want to address her concerns.

“We are extremely disappointed that the state of Maine has chosen not to address our concerns regarding this serious issue,”

What she is really saying is that because Maine wasn’t willing to cave in because of threats from a frivolous lawsuit, prompted by a bunch with a selfish and asinine agenda, she opted to carry through with the lawsuit.

API needs to get a life.

Tom Remington

Share

Sinapu Will Sue To Stop Trapping Mink and Marten

Wendy Keefover-Ring, a representative of the Boulder, Colorado based animal rights group Sinapu, announced the organization’s plan to file a lawsuit to stop the trapping of marten and mink in that state.

In July, the Colorado Wildlife Commission approved a request by the Colorado Trappers Association to use box traps to catch mink and marten. Their request to trap seven other species was denied.

In 1996, Colorado passed by referendum a constitutional ban on leg-hold traps, traps that kill instantly, snares and poison. The box trap was not included in that list, so the CTA petitioned the CWC to be allowed to trap the animals using box traps.

Keefover-Ring says the action by the Commission violates the constitutional ban on trapping. The Trappers Association believes the use of box traps will stand up under the scrutiny of the court.

*Previous Posts*
Colorado Okays Trapping Mink and Pine Marten

Tom Remington

Share

Animal Rights Group Files Suit Against Minnesota DNR

The Animal Protection Institute has filed a lawsuit against the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources claiming that the state is violating the Endangered Species Act by allowing trapping that is killing wildlife listed on the ESA list.

According to a story filed by Bob Kelleher of Minnesota Public Radio, Camilla Fox, a spokesperson for the API, claims to have documented proof that trapping has resulted in the death of 24 bald eagles over a 15-year period of time.

Fox says her group has accumulated documentation that at least 24 bald eagles have been trapped in Minnesota over a 15-year period. At least half died. She says more recent documents show that rare Canada lynx have been caught.

“Between 2002 and 2005, at least 13 Canada lynx have been incidentally trapped in snares and traps set for other species,” says Fox. “And generally these types of traps are set for fox, coyote, bobcat, fisher, martin.”

These are all predators, she says, that are found in the same areas where Canada lynx may live and hunt.

The suit is asking that the MDNR look at ways of changing how trapping is done so as not to harm these animals. No suggestions were given as part of the suit.

Gary Meis, president of the Minnesota Trappers Association doesn’t buy into the so-called documented proof that Fox claims to have.

“I know of no cases myself,” Meis says. “I hear rumors. But I have never seen it or witnessed it myself.”

Meis wonders how serious a problem it can be if it’s that rare. And he says trapping is not the way most endangered animals die.

“I could bet my bank account against theirs, that there’s more endangered animals that are hit by cars, trains, etc., than are caught by traps,” says Meis.

And Meis wonders whether the Animal Protection Institute’s motive is to protect endangered animals.

“Well, they have an agenda, just like all organizations have an agenda,” Meis says. “It’s my personal opinion that they’d just like to put an end to trapping. Their opinion is that they have a legal opening under the Endangered Species Act to go about doing that. And we disagree wholeheartedly.”

Tom Remington

Share

Attention New Hampshire Trappers!

53rd ANNUAL TRAPPERS RENDEZVOUS, SEPTEMBER 16-17 HOLDERNESS, N.H.—

On September 16-17, the New Hampshire Trappers Association (NHTA) will hold their 53rd Annual Trappers Rendezvous at the New Hampshire Fish and Game Department’s Owl Brook Hunter Education Center in Holderness, featuring ongoing demonstrations, trapping supply vendors and activities for the kids.

Rendezvous attractions will be open from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. on Saturday, September 16; and from 8 a.m. to 1 p.m. on Sunday, September 17. Interested members of the public are welcome to attend.

The N.H. Trappers Association annual fall meeting will take place on Sunday from 1 – 3 p.m.

For a complete schedule of activities, directions to Owl Brook, and more, visit the NHTA website at http://www.nhtassoc.org and click on “Rendezvous Details” or call Fish and Game’s Owl Brook Hunter Education Center at (603) 536-1290. The Fall Rendezvous promises to be educational, with demonstrations of trapping techniques happening throughout the weekend. Demonstrations will be conducted by New Hampshire Trappers Association members long experienced in trapping, and will cover topics such as skinning and pelting techniques, trapping of canine species such as coyote and fox, basic trap preparation, trapping beaver under the ice, mink trapping, nuisance animal trapping, the flat set and beaver trapping with conibears.

Trapping supply vendors will be on hand at the event to help you get outfitted for the upcoming trapping season. Fish and Game will hold a Trapper Education certification course during the weekend (this course is full; for other trapper education class opportunities, visit http://www.wildlife.state.nh.us/).Activities will be happening throughout the event for children and families. Be sure to visit the old-time Trapper’s Cabin and check out the life-sized “Forever Locked” exhibit of two battling bull moose, presented by the Conservation Officers Relief Association.

Tom Remington

Share

What is Happening to the Trapping Industry?

Dave Anderson, Director of Education for the Society For The Protection of New Hampshire Forests, has an article this morning in the Concord Monitor about the waning trapping industry in that state and surrounding areas.

Whether you are into trapping or not, this article is loaded with information that is important to all of us who respect the outdoors and in particular, its wildlife. I recommend the read.

Tom Remington

Share